Providing Better Website Feedback

Monday, February 15, 2010 | BY Andrew

I've been thinking a lot lately about how we can provide better website feedback to our members. How can we go beyond what we have already to give users the targeted, actionable reviews they're looking for? I'm far from coming up with an answer, but these are some of the things percolating in the back of my mind:

  • Demographic Targeting - Giving users the ability to invite reviewers in their target market (young adults, web designers, church pastors, etc.).
  • Markup Tools - Giving reviewers the tools they need to make notes, draw shapes and markup the concept.
  • Improved Reputation Scores - Updating our reputation score logic so a member's score is more reflective of his or her ability and knowledge, than length of membership and participation level (this update is in the works).
  • Incentives for Quality Reviews - Providing an incentive, whether it be monetary or otherwise, to help elicit the best quality feedback possible.

Fortunately, we're already on the right path with a growing, active community that consistently provides quality feedback. But what do you think? What ideas do you have to make Concept Feedback indispensable for website design review?

9 Comments:

Anonymous said...

I think these are great ideas!

One thing I would really like is to decrease the number of people who abuse the system by just copying/pasting feedback on various concepts in order to meet their minimum number of reviews (I've seen this happen a few times since I've joined). Perhaps the incentive idea would help. Another option would be to have a "report" button for the comment that would cause it to become unpublished after so many people have clicked on it.

The improved reputation scores idea is also intriguing - I'll be excited to see how that works :)

Anonymous said...

Leave it as is! It works don't fix it. The answer can be found in subtlety. I do prefer the Concepts page as the home page, I can go digging straight away and get a good idea of what your site is all about.

Andrew said...

Thanks for the feedback. I agree, a "report" button is something we've had on the list for a while - the question is how to implement it cleanly. Ideally it would be automated, so a review would be removed, and reputation would be reduced if a user were abusing the system.

Comment #2 - I understand what you are saying about the Concepts page, however, I want to make sure people understand the goal of the site as soon as they get there (which is why we added the landing page). I don't people to assume we are another gallery site, which is the impression most people get when they see the concepts page - we are all about quick, actionable feedback.

Thanks again for sharing your thoughts!

Joe Mulberry said...

Loving the site so far! Big pat on the back to you and it has really helped me with my design process and getting the little details right.

I would like to see the implementation of a more intricate reputation scoring system.

When people review my concept I firstly try and work out if their opinion is worth listening to if it goes against my gut feeling. Currently I do this by checking the reputation points but often look at their concepts and sometimes their other reviews. All in all this takes me a few minutes but I would prefer it if I could see the following:

% of their reviews that have been voted up
% of their reviews that have been voted down
Number of times their concepts that been voted up
Number of times their concepts that been favourited.

I would also like the option for concept authors to vote on reviews/users that have actually helped them improve their design. A way of highlighting users that add to the creative process. I think this would encourage reviewers to provide actionable feedback and be patted on the back for provided actionable feedback that has helped the design progress.

and finally! I am torn between creating a new concept or replacing my image when i make slight changes.. if i add a new image then i am worried people will review old design as well. Also reviews become outdated when I change images. but if i create a new concept then i lose the reviews and the favourites, the views, etc and have to start building up the street cred of the design once again. I would love to see a way of progressing the design slightly and that being kept track of without having to create a new concept.

and finally finally...... is there a way of making the automated tweets when a concept reaches 3 favourites to be more personal? maybe a randomised intro to each tweet from a selection of a intros like "wow! check this one:" "this one is starting to get some love" etc (maybe not as cheesy as mine but you get the idea) ??

finally finally finally promote this blog more!

Andrew said...

Hi Joe,

All great comments, thank you! Most of them are already coded and will be released in the next week or so. The items that aren't are now under consideration. Keep checking back - we appreciate the feedback!

Andrew

Zheng junxai5 said...

zhengjx20160617
cheap toms
coach outlet clearance
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet online
gucci bags
michael kors outlet clearance
nfl jerseys
air jordan homme
true religion outlet online
michael kors purses
hollister clearance
replica rolex watches
louis vuitton handbags
jordan 3 retro
tiffany and co jewelry
kobe shoes
michael kors outlet
fitflops
michael kors canada outlet
ghd flat iron
air jordan femme
coach outlet online
coach factory outlet
louis vuitton handbags
adidas outlet store
hollister jeans
concord 11
fitflop shoes
tory burch outlet online
tiffany and co
abercrombie outlet
oakley outlet
gucci belts
air jordan shoes
coach outlet
true religion outlet
louboutin shoes
toms wedges
kate spade outlet
louis vuitton outlet

Chenzhen 20160303chenzhen said...

valentino bags
chi flat iron
fitflops
timberland uk
ugg boots
true religion uk
north face uk
air max
gucci borse
air max 90
kate spade outlet
abercrombie outlet
yeezy boost 750
nike blazer
ralph lauren uk
coach factory outlet
cheap jordan shoes
christian louboutin outlet
cheap jordan shoes
dior sunglasses 2016
nike tn pas cher
polo ralph lauren
tory burch outlet online
michael kors outlet stores
lacoste polo shirts
polo ralph lauren outlet online
yeezy boost 350
ecco outlet
ray-ban sunglasses outlet
canada goose outlet
nike store uk
coach outlet online
michael kors outlet clearance
fake oakleys
coach outlet online
louis vuitton borse
chenzhen2016622

Zheng junxai5 said...

zhengjx 20170313
air max 2017
michael kors outlet online
james harden shoes
cheap jordans
skechers outlet store
adidas yeezy boost
adidas nmd runner
yeezy shoes
hermes belt for sale
nike dunks shoes

Avaya Duggu said...

Great post
Happy Mother’s Day Quotes
Happy Mothers Day 2017 Images
Mothers Day Poems daughter
Happy Mothers Day quotes sayings

Post a Comment