10 Rules for Better Design Feedback

Wednesday, September 2, 2009 | BY Andrew

Hi All! Our community is expanding quickly, and I'm glad to see people are enjoying the site. Hopefully you're getting some great feedback too! Below is a recent blog post I did for DesignM.ag, thought you might find it useful -- Andrew

Everyone loves to get feedback, but it’s not always easy to get the feedback you need, the kind of feedback that brings a fresh perspective and valuable insight to your project. Whether you are a professional designer, freelancer, client, friend or boss, learning to give and receive effective feedback is an essential skill. Here are 5 simple rules you can apply today to make sure you get the right feedback:

1. Start by clarifying the objective

What is the goal of your project? Make sure the people offering you feedback know exactly what is. The response you receive should revolve around better ways to achieve this objective.

2. Be specific

Let people know what it is you want feedback on, don’t be shy. The more specific you are, the better advice you will get.

3. Listen

As obvious as this rule may seem, it’s easy to turn away ideas because they’re different from your own. But keep in mind, a different perspective is exactly what you’re looking for and may be just what you need.

4. Invite constructive criticism

How well do you deal with criticism? For most people, their first reaction is to get defensive, or even lash out. However, oftentimes specific, thoughtful criticism can be much more useful than a generic positive remark. Don’t let your pride get in the way and pass up a great opportunity to take honest feedback at face value, and improve.

5. Take the advice

Not all of it, but take the time to sort the good from the bad and implement the changes. Don’t just get feedback for feedback’s sake. Not only will this improve your work, it will make your contributors feel appreciated (speaking of which – be sure to say “thank you!”).

Getting feedback is the fun part, but what about giving it?

1. Be respectful

You all know the Golden Rule, and that’s about all this first point boils down to. Acknowledge the hard work the designer has put in and be sensitive to their situation. Are they a newbie? Are they actively seeking advice? Always make sure that this respect is reflected in your critiques.

2. Be specific

The more specific you can be, the better. Try to avoid generic comments like “change the font”, and instead provide specific, actionable suggestions. Offering alternatives, sketches and details ensure that you are both on the same page.

3. Provide justification

Do you have a reason behind your feedback, or is it just your intuition? Whenever possible, provide examples, resources or educated reasoning that back up the advice you are offering to avoid a “battle of opinions”. If it’s just your intuition from experience, that’s fine, but let them know that.

4. Balance the positives and negatives

A healthy balance of pros and cons keeps everyone happy. Never underestimate the confidence-boosting power of a compliment, but by the same token, be open and direct with criticism. Remember, honest, well-meaning criticism can make the greatest impact.

5. “Have you Considered?”

When dealing with a newbie or “sensitive” designer (you know the type), try framing your criticism with “have you considered…”. This gives the designer the opportunity to offer their reasoning and not feel “under attack”.

Additional Resources:

Do you have feedback tips or advice from your own experiences? Let us know, we’d love to hear about it!

24 Comments:

Romany said...

thanks

Romany Salama said...

الغردقة
فنادق الغردقة
رحلات الغردقة
عروض ترافيل
شركة
جولدرس

Chuyên viên cho vay tín chấp said...

vay tin chap ngan hang
vay tin chap ngan hang prudential
vay tin chap ngan hang bidv
vay tin chap ngan hang vpbank
vay tin chap ngan hang agribank
vay tin chap ngan hang vietinbank
vay tin chap ngan hang vietcombank
vay tin chap ngan hang eximbank
vay tin chap ngan hang acb
vay tin chap ngan hang dong a
vay tín chấp ngân hàng
vay tín chấp ngân hàng prudential
vay tín chấp ngân hàng bidv
vay tín chấp ngân hàng vpbank
vay tín chấp ngân hàng agribank
vay tín chấp ngân hàng vietinbank
vay tín chấp ngân hàng vietcombank
vay tín chấp ngân hàng eximbank
vay tín chấp ngân hàng acb
vay tín chấp ngân hàng dong a
vay khong the chap
vay không thế chấp
vay tin chap
vay tín chấp
vay von ngan hang
vay vốn ngân hàng

Chuyên viên cho vay tín chấp said...

vay tín chấp ngân hàng sacombank

vay tin chap ngan hang sacombank

vay tín chấp ngân hàng techcombank

vay tin chap ngan hang techcombank
Vay tín chấp Prudential
Vay tín chấp BIDV
Vay tín chấp VPBank 
Vay tín chấp Vietcombank
Vay tín chấp Eximbank
Vay tín chấp Agribank
Vay tín chấp Sacombank
Vay tín chấp ACB
Vay tín chấp Đông Á
Vay tín chấp Techcombank
Vay tín chấp Vietinbank
Vay tin chap Prudential
Vay tin chap BIDV
Vay tin chap VPBank 
Vay tin chap Vietcombank
Vay tin chap Eximbank
Vay tin chap Agribank
Vay tin chap Sacombank
Vay tin chap ACB
Vay tin chap Dong A
Vay tin chap Techcombank
Vay tin chap Vietinbank

Minh Giap said...

Vay tín chấp là gì
Lãi suất vay ngân hàng
vay tín chấp ngân hàng prudential
vay tín chấp ngân hàng bidv
vay tín chấp ngân hàng vpbank
vay tín chấp ngân hàng eximbank
vay tín chấp ngân hàng vietcombank
vay tín chấp
vay thế chấp
lãi suất vay tín chấp
lãi suất vay ngân hàng
vay không thế chấp
vay vốn ngân hàng
vay tiêu dùng
vay tín dụng
Vay tin chap la gi
Lai suat vay ngan hang
vay tin chap ngan hang prudential
vay tin chap ngan hang bidv
vay tin chap ngan hang vpbank
vay tin chap ngan hang eximbank
vay tin chap ngan hang vietcombank
vay tin chap
vay the chap
lai suat vay tin chap
lai suat vay ngan hang
vay khong the chap
vay von ngan hang
vay tieu dung
vay tin dung

Minh Giap said...

Vay tín chấp là gì
Lãi suất vay ngân hàng
vay tín chấp ngân hàng prudential
vay tín chấp ngân hàng bidv
vay tín chấp ngân hàng vpbank
vay tín chấp ngân hàng eximbank
vay tín chấp ngân hàng vietcombank
vay tín chấp
vay thế chấp
lãi suất vay tín chấp
lãi suất vay ngân hàng
vay không thế chấp
vay vốn ngân hàng
vay tiêu dùng
vay tín dụng
Vay tin chap la gi
Lai suat vay ngan hang
vay tin chap ngan hang prudential
vay tin chap ngan hang bidv
vay tin chap ngan hang vpbank
vay tin chap ngan hang eximbank
vay tin chap ngan hang vietcombank
vay tin chap
vay the chap
lai suat vay tin chap
lai suat vay ngan hang
vay khong the chap
vay von ngan hang
vay tieu dung
vay tin dung

dada xu said...

ralph lauren outlet
adidas ultra boost
fitflops sale
adidas
michael kors
polo ralph lauren outlet online
adidas sneakers
longchamp pliage
coach outlet store
adidas nmd runner
chenshanshan20170311

emma duggu said...

Thanks for the information about this Really nice Post.
memorial day sayings pictures
Inspiring Memorial Day Quotes sayings
happy memorial day weekend

emma duggu said...

Great post. Thanks for Posting. Its very impressive and interesting.
ememorialday
happy memorial day 2017 images
memorial day weekend 2017

eva cooper said...

Happy Mothers Day 2017 Images Happy Mothers Day quotes sayings
Happy Mothers Day pictures free
Happy Mother’s Day 2017
Happy Mothers Day 2017 Images
Mothers day HD Wallpaper Download
Happy Mothers Day pictures free

chenlina said...

ferragamo belt
louis vuitton handbags
christian louboutin
vans shoes
canada goose outlet
michael kors outlet
ray ban sunglasses
christian louboutin uk
converse shoes
toms outlet
chenlina20170503

avaya duggu said...

Happy Fathers Day 2017 Messages
Fathers Day Messages from Daughter
Happy Fathers Day Quotes Images

avaya duggu said...

Happy Fathers Day 2017
Fathers Day 2017 Date
Father’s Day Gifts from Daughter

emma duggu said...

ememorialday
happy memorial day images
memorial day weekend

emma duggu said...

memorial day sayings pictures
Inspiring Memorial Day Quotes sayings
Happy Memorial Day Clip Art

Savvy Rehab said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Savvy Rehab said...

inspirational memorial day wallpapers pictures 2017
inspirational memorial day wallpapers images 2017

alan morris said...

Happy 4th Of July images
Fourth of July Fireworks and Celebrations
Happy 4th of July Images

alan morris said...

Happy 4th of july quotes
Happy 4th of July Pictures HD
Happy 4th of July Wishes 2017
USA Independence Day Speech

shubefdk said...

FATHERS DAY
FATHERS DAY QUOTES
FATHER'S DAY POEMS
FATHERS DAY QUOTES

alan morris said...

Happy 4th of July Flag 2017: Flag of America is not just a piece of cloth but a matter of pride for every citizen of the country where it stands for the pride of the country and wave in the air to represent the nations.
4th of July 2017
USA Independence Day Quotes
US INDEPENDENCE DAY HISTORY
4th Of July Greetings

alan morris said...

Freedom is something that money can't buy.. And most honorable of all are the ones who defend it. So on this 4th of July. Let's salute those who stand in service to America!
Happy 4th of july quotes
Happy 4th of July Pictures HD
Happy 4th of July Message for Facebook
Fourth of July Flag Images

chenlina said...

nike outlet store
mbt shoes
true religion jeans
coach outlet
ralph lauren outlet
polo ralph lauren
polo ralph lauren outlet
kate spade outlet store
ralph lauren outlet
fred perry shirts
20170627wanglili

Anonymous said...

HOW MIKE LARRY LOAN FIRM GRANTED ME A BUSINESS LOAN!!!
Hello everyone, I am Evans Torttor from USA and want to use this medium to express gratitude to MIKE LARRY for fulfilling his promise by granting me a loan, i was stuck in a financial situation and needed to refinance and pay my bills as well as start up a Business. I tried seeking for loans from various loan firms both private and corporate organizations but never succeeded and most banks declined my credit request. But as God would have it, i was introduced by a friend named Esther to MIKE LARRY LOAN FIRM and undergone the due process of obtaining a loan from the company, to my greatest surprise within 48hrs just like my friend Esther said, i was also granted a loan of $387,000.00 USD; So my advise to everyone who desires a loan, "if you must contact any firm with reference to securing a loan online with low interest rate of 3% and better repayment plans/schedule, please contact MIKE LARRY LOAN FIRM. Besides, he doesn't know that am doing this but due to the joy in me, i'm so happy and wish to let people know more about this great company whom truly give out loans, it is my prayer that GOD should bless them more as they put smiles on peoples faces. You can contact them via email on {mikelarryloanfirmworldwide@yahoo.com}

Post a Comment